EP 21 – The story of the man who de-Indianized India’s education system forever

EP 21 – The story of the man who de-Indianized India’s education system forever


Who hasn’t heard this rhyme in nursery? I was taught this rhyme as well, it is taught even today and probably it shall be taught till eternity. When this rhyme is taught in Nursery, the kids merely nod and repeat the same. There is no rocket science in understanding how many of them actually know the meaning of this rhyme, since the answer is crystal clear: ZERO. Now you would ask how children under the age of three would know the meaning of those rhymes. However, the question that flashes in your brain is irrational because infants have immense ability to understand from a young age. Our children, however, do not understand the meaning of the afore mentioned rhymes because it is not in their language. English is not the language of India. It is a foreign language forcibly imposed on India. India’s native language is Sanskrit and if we talk about other languages, then Hindi, Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Malayalam, Gujarati, Bengali, Marathi, Oriya, Konkani, Punjabi, Bhojpuri, Awadhi, Magahi, Maithili etc are languages of our own. So the question arises, how did English become so important in India, which is jeweled with so many languages? Which institution imposed it ? Which person suggested it for the first time? Before beginning with Macaulay’s Tale, let me introduce you to a book, which gave me the inspiration for this episode. This is the book penned by Sankrant Sanu, It strikes at the concept prevalent in India, wherein English education is the sole indicator for development. This book motivates us towards the development of self-respect and pride by being conscious and aware of the language, and each of our listeners must read this book. We have given its link in the description section of the video. Now let’s have a look at Thomas Babington Macaulay. The year was 1813, when a manifesto was promulgated. According to this manifesto, the responsibility of education of ‘uneducated and uncivilized Indians’ was now with the British East India Company. Thomas Babington Macaulay subsequently arrived in India in 1834, upon whose arrival he was declared the head of the General Committee of Public Instruction. A few words sprung from Macaulay’s mouth as he stepped onto the shore of India: This means – After spending three months at sea, being on land is a pleasant feeling, but not on such land [India]. How are the people here – black faces, white turbans and loose-fitting clothes, the trees here are not likeour trees, the air is fragrant and the buildings here are as bizarre as the vegetation. Yes, this was the view of the head of the General Committee of Public Instruction of India towards India and Indians. Prior to the Macaulay period, education in India was mainly in Sanskrit and elsewhere in Arabic. But Macaulay immediately started the Anglicization of India. In 1835 Macaulay gave a fiery speech which would later become known as Macaulay’s minute. The so-called reforms proposed by Macaulay can be listed in these section:- 1) English is far more civilized and sophisticated than Arabic and Sanskrit 2) English is the most influential of the Western languages. India is under the British, so it is natural that the English language should be promoted in India so that trade and commerce can be conducted smoothly. 3) By studying English, India will be able to connect with the world [specifically the English] and be civilized and cultured like them. 4) Every Indian wants to learn English because they too seem to perceive Sanskrit and Arabic as inferior to English. 5) If the British want it, English language intellectuals can also emerge in India. 6) Only by English language can it be ensured that there are people born in India who are Indians by color and blood but English by ideology. Macaulay also threatened that if the reforms proposed by him were not promulgated, he would resign immediately and leave for England. The then Governor General of India, Lord William Bentinck, wasn’t too keen on implementing Macaulay’s suggestions, but he changed his mind and implemented this immediately, allowing no room for discussion. The reason behind this was his own experience in experience in Madras in 1807, when he was dismissed from the Governorship for his alleged insensitivity to Indian religions and customs. By introducing the controversial new policy on the eve of his departure, Bentinck perhaps calculated that he would succeed in avoiding a similar humiliation. However, Lord Bentinck refused to close the already existing Sanskrit and Arabic schools in order to avoid powerful groups from the Hindu and Muslim communities becoming hostile. Macaulay’s proposal was made a state manifesto and after its promulgation, many Christian missionary schools in India were opened and laid the foundation of the present Indian education system. Seeing his dream come true, delighted Macaulay wrote a letter to his father, as I read a part of it to you :- “Our English schools are flourishing wonderfully. We find it difficult, indeed, in some places impossible, to provide instruction for all who want it. At the single town of Hoogly fourteen hundred boys are learning English. The effect of this education on the Hindoos is prodigious. No Hindoo, who has received an English education, ever remains sincerely attached to his religion. . Some continue to profess it as matter of policy; but many profess themselves pure Deists, and some embrace Christianity.” Today, there is neither the British government, nor Thomas Babington Macaulay, but if there is something remaining, it is the Englishness. While language enriches India culturally, language has also been the cause of wars and division. What is the reason that a person moving from Uttar Pradesh or Bihar or Rajasthan to South India interacts with the local people in English rather than learning Telugu, Kannada, Malayalam or Tamil? What is the reason that while there are protests about Hindi in South India, but no one puts a question mark on the presence of English in South India and its importance? This was the vision that Macaulay had seen. Even today in India, people who know English are considered as venerable, great, and intellectual. The knowledgeable writers and writers of Hindi and regional languages are confined in their respective regions. No university admits a person if marks are low in English; if one is not proficient in English; one has to face humiliation in the interview. Why our children today recite rhymes like these without hesitation:- There are numerous question, but the answer is just one. The answer is rooted in our self respect, it lies in the mindset of that mentality according to which the English language is supreme and other languages are only its slave. In today’s globalized world, complete exclusion of English is impossible but respect and uplift of our languages is absolutely necessary whether it is Sanskrit or Hindi or Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Malayalam, Gujarati, Bengali, Marathi, Oriya, Konkani, Punjabi, Bhojpuri, Awadhi, Magahi, Maithili or any other regional language. This was the tale of the imposition of a foreign language on Sanskrit-speaking India, the disposition of Sanskrit, the legend of disrespecting territorial languages, and the story of a cynical white who enslaved us to a foreign language for eternity.

100 thoughts on “EP 21 – The story of the man who de-Indianized India’s education system forever

  1. Start with renaming your channel as "Niraash Bharatiya".

    The world has forced itself to accept the fact that English is the international lingua franca. We can't change history.

    So as Indians, let us treat English for what it is, a tool to enable communication with the rest of the world. Learning it purely for business communication is more than enough. We don't need to learn English nursery rhymes or plays and poems by Shakespeare or Bernard Shaw or Tennyson as a part of our school curriculum to learn the language.

    Clarification: I am not being disrespectful of the great authors and poets of the English language. I'm merely saying we don't need them as a part of our school curriculum to learn English. Whoever is interested in the literature can pursue it at a personal level, but there's no need for it to be a part of the compulsory school curriculum.

  2. We need to start respecting using and keep use of English to the minimum. Get our heritage back. Let go of this assumption that if you don’t know English you are not good for anything. English is a must no absolutely not. Encourage yourself to learn a few different Indian languages before you go to learn French German Russian Japanese or Chinese. Our schools also should have a option of learning another Indian language of the students choice. Our institutions like IIT IIM and our public services interviews should not make English compulsory. These should judge the candidate on the technical subjects and check his mastery on it. But English should not given too much importance.

  3. Video ka title English mein…channel ka naam English..or video hindi or sanskrit ki importance pe…waah 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

  4. If Sanskrit,/ Hindi,/ or any language( especially Sanskrit) is made mandatory as one subject from play home to degree, definitely we make success in removing English from our country.
    Even it is better if all subjects are toght in sanskrit, sanskrit will rule the world. Because Sanskrit is scientific lounge.

  5. Tragedy is this that i need to express myself in English even after listening the presentation.

    However it may sound, still we INDIAN might be good slaves but then we had never lost our brains. A matter of fact is this that even after 2000 years of non-violence towards the HINDOOS we can trace back our beliefs & knowledge flawlessly. Our ancestors, if had not taken some crazy decisions we have had lost all like our brethren.

    As an INDIAN i feel it should be our demand & even our policy that all major 22 langauges recognised under CONSTITUTION should be atleast taught in all schools for knowledge purpose & stress should be on understanding & reading not for grades. Then only INDIA can become one nation. I am doing my bit by telling as many as possible but also following it diligently. Let's see what can be achieved.

  6. What a grate effort to promote our own language, ie. Sanskrit is the mother of all language. Good job sir. Keep it up……

  7. Meccole Jaise kitne kutte aaye chale Gaye Hindu dharma ka kuch nahi ukhad sakge hum kal bhi Hindu the aaj bhi he humesha rahege Jai hind vande matram

  8. Don't worry bro, the day will come definitely when Britishers regret why they teach English to us. When we ahead of whole world.

  9. इंग्लिश एक no ki jandu लैंग्वेज है भोसड़े की इतनी गुस्सा अति है बेंडचोड।

  10. आपकी हिंदी संस्कृतनिष्ट है
    मुझे आपकी हिंदी बहोत अच्छी लगती है

  11. NOW ANDHRA GOVT. CONVERTING ALL TELUGU MEDIUM SCHOOLS TO ENGLISH MEDIUM.
    YOGI ADITYANATH CONVERTED 5000 SCHOOLS TO ENSURE MEDIUM

    TOTAL SELF DESTRUCTION & SELF-SABOTAGE

  12. क्या अँगरेज़ हिंदी में पढ़ते है ? क्या अँगरेज़ के बैंक और दफ्तरों में हिंदी चलती है ? क्या वो संसद में अंग्रेजी में बहस करते है ?

    तो हम भारतीयो पर क्यों 7658 किलोमीटर दूर एक छोटे से टापू की भाषा थोप रखी है ?

  13. I am from south india and i agree that we have slave mentality. We prefer english over our national language. Shame on us.

  14. Abe chutiye Macaulay ka raag alaapnaa band kar re bhai. Macaulay 1947 se desh se nikal chuka hai, uske baad humne kya kiya. Ek musalman ko hrd/education minister banwa diya. Uske baad Maulana Azad ne Romila Thapar ko chuna bharatiya itihaas likhne ke liye

  15. Mishraji agree with you but if Englishman not introduced English you kept continue unreachable habit in India. Before blame anyone , you should look inside you why Indian society was divided.

  16. In India After 70 year of Independence still casteism is exiting. Why not make one video on it, mishraji don't make fool people of India any more

  17. Our country was slave country for long time by Muslim and Englishman , do you know key reason that is casteism. Indian people never come as unity just because of casteism which was spread by ( I don't want explain) , because you already know mishraji.

  18. काश्मीरी हिन्दुओं के दर्द को महसूस करने के लिए इस खबर को देखें। https://zeenews.india.com/hindi/india/video/dna-analysis-of-columnist-sunanda-vashisht-on-kashmiri-pandit-exodus/597290

  19. दोस्तो ।बहुत सीधी सी बात यह है कि दुनिया के सभी सम्पन्न देश अपनी मात्र भाषा में ही उनति करते हैं, हम जैसे देश को छोड़ कर ।जापान,फ्रांस,चीन, सभी अपनी ही भाषा में कार्यरत हैं ।विगत७३वर्षों से हम मात्र बाते ही कर रहे हैं, पर कार्यवाही शून्य है ।

  20. Shame on those who follow bollywood blindly 😞😞. Many of the Bollywood actress and actor are shamed talking in hindi 😞🙏.

  21. अपने आप को हिंदू कहना और पाखंड में विलीन रहना भी गलत शिक्षा(१८ पुराण)का प्रभाव है।

  22. राजीव दीक्षित जी का अंग्रेज़ी भाषा पर बना वह वीडियो सभी को देखना चाहिए, आंखे खोल देगा।

  23. His Education Policy wiped out our Guru Shiysh culture of India…
    Showing Our culture inferior he brainwashed our generation

  24. Atul mishra ji aapse nivedan h ki aap Bharat ke phele Siksha mantri Abul kalam ajad ke bare mai bhi ek video banaye jisne Bharat ke History or Sanskriti ko mitane ke koshis ki or 70 year tak kamyab bhi raha iske bare mai please jarur bataye..

  25. एक सेक्युलर की सच्ची कहानी —

    तो कहानी ऐसे आरम्भ होती है मित्रों कि दानिश, आकाशबाबू के मुहल्ले में रहा करता था और दोनों मित्रों में सच्ची और गहरी मित्रता थी ।

    दोनो मिलकर गंगा जमुनी संस्कृति और भाईचारे के गीत गाते और साम्प्रदायिक शक्तियों को खूब फटकार लगाया करते थे ।

    दानिश,आकाशबाबू से हमेशा कहा करता कि यार, हम सब भाईचारा चाहते हैं कोई आपस मे नही लड़ना चाहता, हमे तो नेता लोग लड़वाते हैं ।

    दानिश की इन बातों से प्रभावित होकर आकाश बाबू पूरे कूल डूड बन चुके थे और कहने लगे थे 'I hate politics.'

    आकाश बाबू ने वोट भी डालना बंद कर दिया क्यों कि उनकी दृष्टि में तो भाई चारे को खराब करने वाले नेता ही थे, वह यह भूल चुका था कि उसके धर्म मे राजनीति को प्रमुख स्थान दिया गया है । इधर दानिश अपने परिवार की महिलाओं तक को वोट डलवाकर आता ।

    धीरे धीरे दानिश के फुफ्फो,ताया, अप्पी के 20-25 लौंडे भी वहीं आकर रहने लगे, और कुछ समय पश्चात उसकी बाजी के 10-12 बच्चे भी वहीं आकर बस गए।

    अब जो दानिश भाई चारे की कसमें खाया करता था वो चुप रहने लगा, उसके चच्चा के लौंडे ने आकाश बाबू की बहन को छेड़ना आरम्भ कर दिया जिसकी शिकायत करने पर आकाश बाबू को दानिश व उसके भाइयो द्वारा बुरी तरह पीट दिया गया ।

    अब आकाश बाबू पुलिस के पास गए पर वहां उसकी एक ना चली, तो उन्हें फिर हिन्दू संगठन के नेताओ की याद आयी, कि वहां जाकर उनकी सहायता से अपनी बहन की इज्जत बचाई जाये ।

    जी हां वही हिन्दू संगठन के नेता जिनको वह और उनका सबसे प्यारा मित्र दानिश दिन रात कोसा करते थे। और भाईचारे की कसमें खाते हुए गंगा-जमुनी संस्कृति के गीत गाया करते थे।

    जब तक वो किसी हिन्दूवादी नेता के पास जाते , दानिश और उसके तहेरे-फुफेरे भाई उसके घर मे घुसकर उसकी प्यारी बहन को उठाकर ले गए, और उसकी बहन की इज्जत लूटने लगे, जब तक आकाशबाबू कुछ समझ पाते उनकी प्यारी बहन की इज्जत लूटी जा चुकी थी ।

    अपनी बहन की चीखों से आकाश बाबू का हृदय फट पड़ा और दुःख और पीड़ा के कारण उनके दोनो नेत्रों से गंगा- जमुनी तहजीब अश्रुधारा धारा बनकर बह निकली ।

    कुछ दिन के पश्चात आकाश बाबू ने वह मुहल्ला छोड़ दिया। अब उस मुहल्ले में गंगा जमुनी संस्कृति और भाईचारे के गीत के स्थान पर अजान की आवाजें सुनाई देती है और दिन में मुर्गे लड़ाए जाते हैं।

  26. Sir please system ko change karne ke lie sarkar ko right kaam karna hoga jab bache apni maa boli mein kuch bh sunte hai wo cheeje jaldi samajhte ha

  27. We can't and won't be able to leave English easily, not because Britain adopted it, but because USA adopted it and has been the lone superpower since the end of cold war. Unless some other nation replaces USA as the world's largest economic and scientific superpower, English will continue to rule the world.

  28. मैं एयरफोर्स के पेपर मै अंग्रेजी मैं ही फेल हो गया था तब मुझे जो दर्द हुआ था। पता नही कब तक हमे सरकारी नौकरी पाने के लिए अंग्रेजी भाषा मैं पेपर देना पडेगा ।

  29. हरामखोर नेहरू ने जो सपना देखा था ये भारत राष्ट्र उसी सपने में जी रहा है, कि मैं (नेहरू) और मेरे परिवार के सिवाय ये राष्ट्र ना किसी और को याद करे और ना ही किसी और महान व्यक्ति के नाम से कुछ बनाया जाए जैसे जवाहरलाल नेहरू विश्वविद्यालय, इंदिरा गांधी एयरपोर्ट आदि, जनता इस बात को जानती थी इसलिए जनता उस व्यक्ति का प्रतिक्षा कर रही थी और वो समय आया २०१४ को जब मोदी जी प्रधानमंत्री बने,बनने के बाद मोदी जी ने बहुत सारे बदलाव किए और साहसिक फैसले तक लिए, कहते हैं ना बिमारी अगर अधिक है तो समय भी अधिक लगेगा राष्ट्र समझ रहा है इस बात को इसलिए तो फिर २०१९ के चुनाव में ३०३ के भारी मतों के साथ मोदी जी को दुबारा प्रधानमंत्री बनाया गया। दुबारा प्रधानमंत्री बनने के बाद ये राष्ट्र ने वो चीज देखा जो किसी प्रधानमंत्री ने आज तक सपने में भी नहीं सोचा था, जम्मू-कश्मीर से धारा ३७० का हटना, मुस्लिम औरतों का हलाला वाला कानून ३ तलाक का हटना और सर्वोच्च न्यायालय का आदेश आना कि अयोध्या में श्री राम जी का मंदिर बनेगा।

  30. Jin logo ne India ko ek behtar country bnaya hm unko abuse krte h or muslims ne India ki history or education hub ko destroy kya unke nam ki road or unko honour dete h. This is shameful.

  31. 1947 में स्वतंत्रता के पश्चात नेहरू को किसने मना किया था कि मैकाले की शिक्षा पद्धति को चालू रखे? देश का पहला शिक्षा मंत्री एक मदरसा छाप मौलाना को बना दिया जिसने इतिहास से हिंदू वीरो की गाथा को गायब कर दिया। मुगलो के अत्याचार को छिपाकर उन्हें महान बना दिया।

  32. Mishraa ji मौलाना अब्दुल कलाम प्रथम शिक्षा मंत्री की गलतियों के बारे में भी बताएं

  33. India ko English ka Nasha chada hua hy,France ,China,Russia,Koria Arab countries koi English nahi bolta Magar vah developed hy aur hamarey log Angrezi ke chakar mey Shash Tharor jiaise Pathni ko Pitney wala murder karne wale ko izath de jathi hy kyu ki vaha acha Angrezi Botha hy 😂😂😂

  34. संस्कृत या तमिल कौन सी भाषा ज्यादा पुरानी है….

  35. अतीउत्तम वीडियो व जानकारी भाईसाब,आप हमें ये बताए कि हम हमारी हिन्दी एक दम शुद्ध कैसे के सकते है?

  36. I believe that you are a little mistaken here. Kindly follow the lines below:
    Rammohun Roy, “Letter to Lord Amherst” (1823)
    Roy wrote this letter to the British governor general, Lord Amherst,
    in 1823, to oppose a British plan to sponsor a school in Calcutta to
    teach Sanskrit and Hindu literature.
    Rammohun Roy, The English Works of Rammohun Roy (Allahabad: Panini
    Office, 1906), 471–74.
    or
    The English works of Raja Rammohun Roy. Edited by Jogendra Chunder Ghose.

    Pre-dates Macaulay's observation.

    Please search Archive.org with string: "English works Raja Rammohun Roy"
    edited "Jogendra Chunder Ghose"

    A good critique is here:
    https://www.sabhlokcity.com/2010/09/indians-wanted-english-language-in-india-well-before-macaulay/

    You could also follow this video:
    Ram Mohan Roy & Decline of Sanskrit
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WRd0gngmFds

  37. भाई, ये सब तो पता है परन्तु इसका हल क्या हो सकता है ये नहीं पता। आप मदद कर सकते हैं, तो कर दीजै।

  38. क्या अभी तक आप ने सुना है कि खुदाई में 5000 साल पुरानी मस्जिद मिली, दरगाह मिली, चर्च मिला या क्रॉस मिला ??

    सिर्फ मंदिर और हिन्दु देवी – देवता की मूर्तियाँ ही क्यों मिलती हैं ??

    क्योंकि पहले सिर्फ मंदिर ही थे!!

  39. I don't like those kind of stupid who have no idea about what Mughals did to Hindus. These kind of people always lived in their own bubble and never cared about anyone else. Akbar and his family has wiped out almost all my family only because of my religion. He was ruler of the time so history was written according to that. But orally we have been told for generations. You may not know Aurangzeb ordered 1 mun or maund (Unit of weight in that time) Hindu sacred threads by killing those many Hindus daily. I won't tell you about my family because judging by name or surname is very common these days. I have no grudge against this new generation but I'm so annoyed with people who try to glorify Mughals.

  40. I've tried to tell Hindus to learn their beautiful Devanagari, but they prefer not to know. Some are such dumbass as to tell it provides job and money to live. Because being so illeterate, they just listen to people, ignorance to acces its own rich science, language, history and more. Hindus are still slave in many, many ways. Not only to the English but to all the languages of Murderers, Rapists, Bookburners, Looters and so. Then there are some very stupid one, who thinks it is only allowed to Brahmanas. How stupid that can be while every adharmi meat-eater is studiying Sanskrit, searching for any scientific clues, solutions as they have done all the time, have stolen many manuscripts, enrich their own European/American culture from our own Sanskrit writings, all stolen. Let Hindus built railways, let Hindus secure it, while the British used it to Loot it faster protected by the stupid Hindus. All the way Hindus were despiced by many of the foreigners and even to this day by our own too, not knowing they the Hindus are in fact the one being despiced, turned Christian, despiced by them as you know what has happened in India. Hindus who do not know their own language, culture, are not recognized or respected. Hindi is not Hindi. Common words for daily use in the house, outside the house, in society, in class, in science, in technic, in space, in mathematics, in physics…. a very long list… is not know in the own Hindi language, while we have such a rich Sanskrit(i) language.
    There are two world languages: 1st is hardly used, but is the best of all… and that is telepathy. The 2nd one is DevaVani (Sanskrit) and in speech highest of all. Real Shuddha Hindi is it madhyam to learn Sanskrit easier.

  41. Agree with most part of this video. Won't agree that South Indians only prefer English. We learn English for wide opportunities outside but its not that we prefer English. For Hindi hatred part, it is present only in Tamilnadu. I am from Andhra and I have Hindi as my 2nd language till 10th class. (I personally prefer to have more science subject then to learn another language)

    I don't think any North Indian learns a South Indian language. Should I attribute that to hatred towards South Indian languages by North Indians. Learning a new language should be personal choice but not imposition.

  42. सच बोलूँ इंग्लिश सीखना मजबूरी है ,लेकिन दिल मेरा संस्कृत सीखना है
    संस्कृत के उच्चरण की बात ही अलग है

  43. Sanskrit is beautiful language must be brought back in all schools compulsorily it has great knowledge of we know Sanskrit we will know our Vedas which has immense knowledge in it modiji pl bring back Jai shree ram other foriegn countries schools HV Sanskrit n look at us what we r doing

  44. Bhi wo sab to thik hai lekin is BAAT par BHI to dhyan do.kewal angrezi Sikh Kar hi hum angrezo key desh main jaa Kar unhi ki naukariya chin rhe hai.ye BHI koi Kam hai kya

  45. दक्षिण भारत के लोग अंग्रेजी को अकारण ही ज्यादा महत्व देते है, उन्हें राष्ट्रभाषा बोलने में लज्जा आती है! इस से एक तरह की देशविरोधी मानसिकता का प्रसार होता है, और अन्य देशवासी उसका अनुसरण करते है।
    उन्होंने राष्ट्रभाषा का सम्मान कर उसमे ही बोलने का प्रयास करना चाहिए और अंग्रेजी का परित्याग करना चाहिए।

  46. Usne भारतिय संस्कृति के bare मे क्या kaha ये भी bataye… Letter मे 🙏🙏🙏

  47. Blame Indians.
    Why?
    Without Indian Hindus and Hindu convert's support, neither the Mongols nor the Brtish would have ruled Indian over 1070 years.
    In present India 99.99% of those belonging to Indic civilization dharma have strong faith, Vedic teaching is bull$hit.
    Have read and understood 0.000001% of Vedic slokas, I would like to work on transform slokas, a contextual thought, to mathematical Graphical models having few deterministic algorithms.

    Stop the blame game and show the benefits of reading and understanding Vedic education.

  48. पहले तो खुद के channel का नाम हिन्दी करो फिर ज्ञान दो ।

  49. aapki saari baatein aatma ko jakhjhor de rahi hai, lekin kya badlega wo to hum logo par hi nirbhar karta hai. fir bhi priya bhrata aapki shudh hindi sun kar mai tript ho gya.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *